Many NFL sports fans (especially those in San Diego) predicted that the Chargers would play in the Superbowl this month. They were, by all accounts, an extremely talented group, arguably among the most proficient in the NFL. Yet, their season ended prematurely in heart-wrenching defeat. Why?
LaDainian Tomlinson may have provided rich insight into one possible answer. He said that he didn’t feel “connected, as far as the team, the unity, the togetherness, family” this past season, and said many players were more about “me” than “faith, family, football.” Whether Tomlinson is expressing sour grapes or reality, his comments hit upon a potent point: talent ALONE is not enough to win the big game.
What is true in sport is also true in business. Although technical expertise, knowledge, and experience are critically important to organizational success, those things alone cannot sustain market share and customer loyalty. In today’s global and competitive economy, the “players” of an organization must be aligned around a core mission, set of values, and principles of behavior. This alignment is what Tomlinson was referring to in his comments about connectedness. Alignment, along with technical competency, composes the complete ingredients for success.
Each organization shapes its own alignment factors. In today’s workplace, prudent leaders carefully scrutinize a candidate’s ability to “fit” these unique alignment factors. Employers are at an advantage right now since many very skilled people are seeking employment. It is a prime time to ensure you make right selection decisions regarding both technical competency and the soft-skills alignment factors.
Increasingly organizations are turning to assessment tools to help predict performance success. Such tools provide organizations with objective and comprehensive information about hidden soft skill potential as it relates to job requirements.
Some of the information these assessments can provide include:
• Communication and problem solving style
• Reactions to conflict and stress
• Ability to manage problems and emotions
• Ability to influence
• Intensity of accountability and results orientation
• Motivational style, including preference for recognition and rewards
• Strengths in interpersonal, operational and strategic thinking
Studies indicate that a comprehensive and validated assessment tool increases your organization’s ability to predict “fit.” In fact, when a comprehensive assessment (including personality, motivation and competency) was compared to an unstructured interview alone: the assessment predicted performance 25 times better! (Scott Lighthouse in Industry and Organizational Psychology 1, 2008, pages 333-342.)
Utilization of assessments in the hiring process is without a doubt a prudent strategic decision. The important question becomes, “which one do you choose?” Before you can determine which assessment tool will meet your organizational needs, it is important to clearly define your objectives and implementation strategy. We have put together a few critical questions to consider when selecting an assessment tool:
1. What is the purpose of the assessment process? If you are using an assessment to improve performance predictability in hiring, make sure the instrument has been validated for selection.
2. What are you attempting to measure? If you are hiring for a lower level position, matching the right personality and motivational driver to the job might be sufficient. However, if you are selecting a technical expert and/or leader, you will also want to assess the candidate’s abilities against the soft-skill competencies required for that job. Compare the attributes being measured by the assessment against those required for the job and your critical alignment factors (mission, values, and principles of behavior).
3. What ongoing support will you receive? You want to look for vendors that will provide active ongoing support and will not simply administer the assessment and deliver the results. Although these both hold value, a trained professional in the assessment brings it all together and provides insight that comes from experience. So, once you have identified the best assessment tool, also choose a reliable and personable business partner.
4. How is the system priced? It is important to clearly understand the fee schedule as it relates to the manner in which you plan to use the test. Ask vendors to outline up-front fees for system design and configuration, as well as ongoing usage fees. Remember, the assessment tool is an investment that enables you to choose the absolute best candidate for your job, team and organization. It is similar to investing in maintenance of machinery or website optimization. Investments return increased productivity and profitability.
We see incredible opportunity for organizations to build teams and increase success this year. As the applicant pool is deep and rich, take time to search for candidates with strong organizational “fit”. Don’t settle for candidates based solely upon technical talent. Pursue those that also are emotionally intelligent, work collaboratively, and contribute innovative and creative ideas. Your organization deserves workers that are aligned and committed to your mission and culture. Utilizing a comprehensive assessment within your hiring process enhances your ability to make an objective and informed decision about candidate “fit” within your unique organization.
Author: Diane Brown at TJ Associates LLC (Talent Journey). Copyright protected, all rights reserved worldwide.
